The Guardian has published a harrowing video.  This video depicts what it’s like to be one of the over a hundred prisoners inside Guantanamo Bay on hunger strikes who are being forcibly fed to keep them alive.

Guantanamo Bay prisoners courtesy Wikipedia

Guantanamo Bay prisoners courtesy Wikipedia

We know the facts:  there are 166 prisoners in Guantanamo Bay.  More than half of them have been cleared to be released, yet they are caught in a Kafka-esque condition in which American and international political bureaucracy keeps them from being released.    This list includes:  26 Yemenis, 12 Afghans, 3 Saudis, 2 Kuwaitis, 2 Libyans, a Kenyan, a Moroccan, and a Somali.

About 120 of these prisoners are on hunger strike, because it is the only way they have left to let the world know of their plight.  So the prisoners have attempted to take the one measure of dignity they should have left to publicize their plight:   refuse to be fed solid food.    Hunger strikes are a last-resort and time-honored method for political prisoners around the world, from Gandhi to the suffragettes movement in the United States to the Irish.   44 of them are being force-fed against their wish.

The political prisoners have written an open letter to their doctors, expressing their reasons for refusing solid food as part of their political protest.

The answer of the United States government has been unfathomable:  rather than working to resolve this standoff and release the prisoners, we have chosen to strap down prisoners using handcuffs and restraint chairs, and have ill-qualified doctors insert tubes down their bodies to have them be force-fed.

In some cases the tubes are being transferred from prisoner to prisoner without having them be cleaned.    Some of the tubes are too large, causing unbearable pain for these prisoners.

So what is it like to be force-fed?

The rapper/actor Mos Def (who now goes by Yasiin Bey) agreed to have these tubes inserted down his nose, and have it be video-taped to publicize the experience of the Guantanamo prisoners.   This was a one-time take.

The British paper Guardian published the video.   

It is disturbing, but has to be seen.

Mos Def in concert courtesy   Wikipedia

Mos Def in concert courtesy

No one was paid for this.   Nor was this a grotesque reality TV stunt.   As the director stated, Yasiin Bey (Mos Def) is a strong, healthy young man who  found the experience of being force-fed unbearably painful.  One can only imagine what it must be like for the emaciated political prisoners who have lost 30-40-50 pounds under the circumstances in Guantanamo.

This was an act to do what the American media has so far failed to do:  publicize one of the great political, ethical, and legal crimes of the last decade, shed light on practices that the United States has stashed away in maximum security islands in a no-man’s land that is designed to escape legal and political scrutiny.

A group of American physicians released a report in which they referred to Guantanamo Bay as a “Medical Ethics-Free Zone”, and slammed the ethics of force-feeding political prisoners:

“Physicians at Guantánamo cannot permit the military to use them and their medical skills for political purposes and still comply with their ethical obligations. Force-feeding a competent person is not the practice of medicine; it is aggravated assault.”

What do the prisoners in Guantanamo Bay about their own experience?  Samir Naji al Hasan Moqbel said in the New York Times:

 “Denying ourselves food and risking death every day is the choice we have made. I just hope that because of the pain we are suffering, the eyes of the world will once again look to Guantánamo before it is too late.”

Samir has been held at Guantanamo Bay for over 11 years. He has never been charged with a crime, and has never received a trial.  It is the experience of men like Samir Naji al Hasan Moqbel that makes a complete mockery of the United States’ claim to be a beacon of democracy in the world today.

A democracy is measured not by how it conducts itself in its political showcases, but rather by how the most marginalized people in society are treated.   And right now the way that the United States is force-feeding political prisoners held indefinitely, uncharged, cleared, and unreleased is a mockery of human rights, decency, and democracy.    It is the responsibility of journalism to shed light precisely on such places, and to expose and educate.

WARNING: Some viewers may find these images distressing.

Watch the video from the Guardian. This is what our government does twice  every day, to dozens of political prisoners.  This has to end.   Today.  The political prisoners who have been cleared must released immediately.   The prisoners deserve that, and the fate of our democratic experiment deserves that.

The Guardian prefaces the video by stating:  “Warning: some viewers may find these images distressing.”
Actually, it’s not the images that are distressing.  It is the current fate of our democracy that should be distressing to all of us.




  2. If they don’t want to eat, then, let them not eat. They want the world to see how they are suffering. I want the world to see how the Christians, Buddhists, Bahais, Hindus, and Jews of the the Middle East have been suffering for decades under Islamic law from paying jizya, to limited religious freedoms to outright murder and enslavement.

    • Omid Safi

      dear Leo, Unless you are holding people accountable for collective punishment, I hope you realize that the prisoners in Guantanamo Bay have been cleared for being released. And your characterization of life of non-Muslims is something out of the JihadWatch handbook. Educate yourself.

      • Omid, Christian persecution has nothing to do with your hatred towards JihadWatch or Robert Spencer. The mistreatment of people simply because they are Christian is replete in the world today. There are Christian sites compiling the information for us from all around the world. Sadly most of the horrific accounts stem from Islamic republics or those countries that aspire to become so. There are of course other countries that persecute Christians as well and they tend to be Atheist.

        • Omid Safi

          “Marty”, whoever you are. Your attempts at misdirection are not going to work. This is not about JihadWatch or Spencer, but about the official policy of the United States of America inflicting forced feeding on citizens of many different countries even after they have been cleared to be released. That is the issueI am talking about here. Some of us realize that injustice happens everywhere around the world, and we see it as our moral responsibility to stand up against it. You make your own choices. Goodbye.

  3. Injustice has been happening with Islam since its founding in 624 when it unprovokedly entered Spain, and if it were not for Charles Martel we would all be on prayer rugs. Even the Buddhists cannot get along with Islam, and that is quite a statement.

    I repeat, if people chose to starve themselves to death for what they consider a greater good, that is, then, their privilege. To take away this right is wrong.

  4. i absolutely agree with you, Safi. U.S, the so-called guardian of human rights is itself a perpetrator of violation of those same rights. and the world needs to stand together to bring it to an end. it is not just in this case that the U.S. has broken international laws but also when it comes to drone attacks or the way they invade into other countries. if only all of us could be united against such heinous acts can a change come because the working of global platforms like UN is nothing but puppetry by U.S. and few other global giants.

  5. The second-in-command of a branch of Al Qaeda has been killed in a U.S. drone strike in Yemen, according to the terrorist group.
    Said al-Shihri rose to become number two of the Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) following his 2007 release from Guantanamo Bay prison.
    Professor, To be force-fed is uncomfortable I imagine and I can see the grimace of the in-mate as he is about to eat against his will but what are we to do?
    So many of the released return to terrorism.
    I challenge you to find a nation that has the kind of democracy you imagine in your head. You are an idealist and as I read more of you I realise that you most often leave out ‘the other side of the story’. What are we going to do with you? We will tolerate you because we live in a secular society. I will love you because I am Christian.

  6. Greetings from California! I’m bored to death at work so I decided to check out your site on my iphone during lunch break. I love the info you present here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m surprised at how fast your blog loaded on my cell phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyways, good blog!|

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 characters available

Comments with many links may be automatically held for moderation.