Christmas is serious.

It’s like Mother’s Day, in that to engage it with someone less than total reverence is to wander into a cultural minefield of the usual inane accusations:

“How dare you wish me a ‘Merry Christmas’?”
“How dare you wish me a ‘Happy Holidays’ instead of ‘Merry Christmas’”?
“Put the Christ back in Christmas.”
“Christmas is ruined with all the commercialized nonsense.”

So at the risk of those insults, I’d like to raise two simpler points about Christmas:   Jesus was Jewish, and Jesus was Palestinian.   Both of these aspects are missing from today’s Christmas celebration.
church of nativity star of Jesus birth site

Both are obvious, yet oddly they seem to be missing from our common celebrations of Christmas.    Jesus was Jewish, but all the Jewish components of this season are banished to the Hanukkah realm.    Christmas is kept safely un-Jewish, unencumbered from anything that might suggest that Jesus was in fact, you know, well, kind of, 100% Jewish.   All the details of his birth, the topography of Christmas seems more suited “timeless”/ “eternal” than the unmistakably 1st century landscape of Jewish Palestine.  And as for the real star of Christmas, that 3rd century Roman saint St. Niklaus from today’s Turkey, well he seems like a jolly ole Dutch fella, recast through the lens of American consumerism.     [Here we go, here comes the hate mail!]

Alas, the tendency to hide Jesus’s Jewishness, his Aramaic language (a Semitic language which is far closer to today’s Arabic and Hebrew than to the Queen’s English) also smacks of lingering anti-Semitic tendencies in today Christianity.

church of nativity shutterstock

The connection between Jesus and Palestine is certainly not lost on Palestinian Christians, one of the oldest indigenous Christian communities in the world:   Latin Patriarch Fouad Twal said this Christmas would be a celebration of “the birth of Christ our lord and the birth of the state of Palestine”.

Leading the Mass at Church of Nativity, the Patriarch went on to say:
“From this holy place, I invite politicians and men of good will to work with determination for peace and reconciliation that encompasses Palestine and Israel in the midst of all the sufferings in the Middle East.”

 

The landscape that Jesus was born in, today’s Palestine, is almost entirely being choked out by illegal Jews-only settlements.  The Guardian reports:  “”For the first time in 2,000 years of Christianity in our homeland, the Holy Cities of Bethlehem and Jerusalem have been completely separated by Israeli settlements, racist walls and checkpoints.”   Yet as most Americans go on celebrating Christmas, we do so without any real connection to the present day reality of what is happening in Jesus’s birthplace, in today’s Palestine, and the harsh realities of occupation there.   Not only is Jesus disconnected from his Jewish roots, he is also disconnected from the atrocities in Palestine.

Mary not getting into Bethlehem

In fact, had Mary and Joseph tried to make their way from Bethlehem to Jerusalem (and other Palestinian sites),

they would encounter many Israeli checkpoints,
Israeli settlements,
and Israeli roads.

 

Recently the Palestinian city of Bethlehem, which contained the Church of Nativity, was given the status of a UNESCO World Heritage Status.    The Church is believed to mark the spot where Jesus was born.

So there you go, Jesus the Jew, Jesus the Palestinian.

 

If Jesus can reconcile in his own being the twin identities of the Jew and the Palestinian, maybe there is hope for Palestine/Israel in our own age.

Palestinians in Church of Nativity

There is hope for a state where the Jew, the Muslim, and the Christian can be reconciled in a state which would recognize equal and identical rights for all the citizens there.    A state in which all the children of Abraham would be free to worship, to live in freedom, and to live side by side.

Merry Christmas, y’all.

11 Comments

  1. Which king of kings ?
    Jer 10:2 “Do not learn the ways of the nations or be terrified by signs in the heavens, though the nations are terrified by them.3 For the practices of the peoples are worthless; theycut a tree out of the forest,and a craftsman shapes it with his chisel.4 They adorn it with silver and gold; they fasten it with hammer and nails so it will not totter.5 Like a scarecrow in a cucumber field,their idols cannot speak;they must be carried because they cannot walk.Do not fear them;they can do no harm nor can they do any good.”
    Sound familiar?

  2. Mood thank you for your article.
    It is nice to see an Islamic man interested in Jewish matters.
    The thing that has me stumped is the fact that Jesus is portrayed as a Palestinian when Palestine never existed in the time Jesus was on this Earth. Yes he was Jewish and born in Bethlehem, and grew up in Nazareth as a member of God’s chosen people, descendants of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob (aka Israel).

    Merry Christmas.

      • Dawud,

        This is not true.

        The Romans did not change the name of the province to Palaestina until after the crushing of the Bar Kokhba revolt which finally ended decades of Roman Jewish war and rebellion with the destruction of Jerusalem and other Jewish towns, the massacre and expulsion of the population and the banning of Judaism.

        This happened about one hundred years after the death of Christ. Before then, the province was called Judea, after the people who lived there. The Jews.

        At the time of Jesus’ birth Judea was ruled by Herod, a vassal king of the Romans, who died when Jesus was an infant. As Herod was a tyrant who executed all members of dynasties with royal claims, including his wife, he died without a successor. He was therefore the last king of Judea.

        From then Judea was ruled direct from Rome by a succession of procurators one of whom was in office at the time of the crucifixion of Jesus.

        There was no Palestine in Jesus’ lifetime. Therefore there were no Palestinians. The people of this province of the Roman empire were known as Jews. Jesus was one of them.

        Jesus was not a Palestinian. It says much about the mindset of the Palestinians, and the prospects for peace, that this claim can be made by Palestinian leaders. .

  3. Jesus’ origin was Jewish with probably other influences. Whether he was an observant Jew is debatable and unlikely since he offended the authorities and did not keep Mosaic law. What’s his point anyway–what should Christians do post banners saying Jesus was a Jew and and spoke Aramaic. Everyone knows this.

    Spend more time on getting Islamic countries to stop their prejudices and persecution of all religions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments with many links may be automatically held for moderation.